Wednesday, July 15, 2015
An Israeli Colonel Responds ToThe Virginia State Bar's Boycott Of Israel
Tuesday, July 14, 2015
In Memoriam: David Grossman ’88, Clinical Professor and Lawyer for the Poor
David Abraham Grossman ’88, a lawyer and teacher who devoted his career to addressing the legal needs of the poor and served as Director of the Harvard Legal Aid Bureau, died on July 12.
Grossman had been director of the Harvard Legal Aid Bureau (HLAB) since 2006, when he was appointed to the position by Elena Kagan, then-dean of Harvard Law School. HLAB provides free legal counsel to indigent clients while simultaneously providing hands-on training to HLS students.
“David devoted his life to pursuing justice with creativity, integrity, and craft–and to inspiring and enabling students to do so as well,” said Martha Minow, Dean of Harvard Law School. “As Clinical Professor, he played pivotal roles both at the WilmerHale Legal Services Center and then as managing attorney and faculty director of the Harvard Legal Aid Bureau, where among other great efforts he guided the nationally recognized Project No One Leaves (PNOL), a nonprofit tenants’ rights organization. In this effort, he made sure that lawyers and law students worked hand-in-hand with clients, community members, and community organizations in bringing legal education to low-income people facing foreclosure and eviction, advancing protections for individuals, families, and communities, changing and enforcing laws, and strengthening the tools and spirit necessary for helping people in serious need. With a formidable intellect and constant courage, David also brought his tremendous humility, humor, and friendship to every encounter, elevating allies and opponents alike. We were truly honored to have his work and leadership and will do our best to continue his vital efforts.”
Grossman began his work with indigent clients as a student at HLS, enrolling in the Legal Services Center (LSC), established by Gary Bellow ’60 and Jeanne Charn ’70. They established the center with the aim of promoting social justice by providing free legal counsel to those in need while simultaneously providing hands-on training to law students.
Grossman found his professional calling at the LSC and found a life-long friend, mentor and role model in Gary Bellow, who died in 2000. About Bellow, Grossman said, “Gary was one of the few people about whom it can accurately be said that he devoted his life to performing mitzvot, or good deeds, to trying to fix a broken world, a concept known in Jewish thought as tikkun olam. But what was even more remarkable about Gary than his own mitzvot was his ability to both inspire and enable others to perform mitzvot of their own, to carry out the work of tikkun olam. Gary was the only one who really inspired me. He was the only professor I knew who was not only thinking about and analyzing how to do the right thing, but was actually spending his life doing it. For that reason, he became my mentor and, in a sense, my hero—someone whom I sought to model my life after.”
Charn, director of the Bellow Sacks Access to Civil Legal Services Project and Senior Lecturer on Law said, “David practiced law at the highest level of craft in service of a relentless commitment to improving housing for residents buffeted by Boston’s volatile markets. His efforts included a focus on strategies that enabled people to help themselves and each other and a concern with cost effective paths to excellent outcomes. He preferred working in teams and knew how to build strong ones. He believed in and modeled rigorous peer review – the heart of the profession’s claim to self-regulation. These qualities made him a compelling teacher in the law office as well as the law school classroom. David was an ardent cause lawyer who never conflated himself with or ceded his life to the cause. He had a sharp wit and warm humor. He was a loyal and caring friend who gave unstintingly when friends were in need. He cherished his wife Stacy and their children Lev and Shayna who were ever his first, most joyous and constant commitment.”
U.S. Representative Joe Kennedy ’09, one of Grossman’s former students, said, “Professor Grossman was a talented lawyer, a dedicated teacher and a passionate advocate. He committed his life to the fair implementation of the law, believing that it applies to all of us and protects each of us. Throughout his career, he showed how words like justice and fairness were not just ideas for discussion but principles that had to be fought for, protected and defended. In so doing, he protected thousands of people in need and inspired hundreds of young lawyers. Our community has lost a champion, but his values and vision live on through all those he touched. My thoughts and prayers are with Stacy, Lev and Shayna during this difficult time.“ In addition, Kennedy planned to read a statement about the impact of Grossman’s work on the floor of the U.S. House this week.
Grossman was born and raised in New Jersey, and spent his adult life in Boston. He graduated from Harvard University summa cum laude in 1980, received a Master’s Degree in Eastern Religions from Harvard Divinity School in 1982, and earned his JD at HLS in 1988.
In 1995, Grossman rejoined LSC as a clinical instructor in the housing unit, after a short stint working for the New York law firm, Kramer Levin and a few years at Community Lawyers in Jamaica Plain, Mass. For 11 years he was the Managing Attorney of the Housing Unit.
While at LSC, Grossman revived the partnership between LSC and City Life/Vida Urbana, a community organization with a focus on tenants’ rights. Together with Steve Meacham, the coordinating director at City Life/Vida Urbana, Grossman developed a combined lawyering and organizing approach to gentrification-driven rent increases. The effort resulted in numerous collective bargaining agreements with developers and landlords guaranteeing long-term stability and affordability for buildings full of tenants who had been threatened with displacement.
Grossman was also involved in initiating, developing, and staffing a “lawyer for the day” program in Boston Housing Court, which has both provided assistance each week to scores of otherwise unrepresented tenants facing eviction and given numerous law students unparalleled educational experience in staffing the law equivalent of an emergency room.
At HLAB David continued to work collaboratively with City Life/Vida Urbana to broaden the scope of HLAB’s role so that it not only provides free legal counsel to those in need, but also enacts real social change to benefit the community at large. In 2007 enormous waves of foreclosures devastated neighborhoods throughout the country and in Boston. Under Grossman’s leadership, HLAB along with City Life/Vida Urbana, adapted their anti-gentrification model into a fierce anti-foreclosure movement.
The anti-foreclosure movement—which now encompasses HLAB, CityLife/Vida Urbana, LSC and many other organizations—works with homeowners and tenants to thwart the efforts of lenders to displace families after foreclosure. Grossman and HLAB students played a key role in this mobilizing effort, canvassing foreclosed properties on a weekly basis, conducting weekly clinics in which they educate occupants about their rights, and deploying a legal “shield” for all of the movement’s members by vigorously defending post-foreclosure evictions through a variety of creative and successful approaches. (The “shield’s work is complemented by that of the “sword”: rallies, protests, and other demonstrations, including acts of civil disobedience, coordinated by City Life/Vida Urbana organizers as a means of calling public attention to the problem of post-foreclosure displacement.)
The movement Grossman helped to initiate has become so effective in Boston that it has inspired activists in cities throughout the country to do the same. Grossman helped to secure generous funding from the Oak Foundation to help finance these efforts for years to come.
Grossman, who fought a courageous seven-year battle with cancer, is survived by his wife, Stacy, his son, Lev, and his daughter, Shayna. He also leaves a sister Rachel, an aunt, Helen Kaplan, and parents-in-law Leonard and Madeline Soave, as well as sisters- and brothers-in-law, nieces, nephews, and cousins. He was predeceased by his parents, Harold and Gloria Grossman.
Donations in his memory can be made to CityLife/Vida Urbana 284 Amory Street, Jamaica Plain, MA 02130 or The Harvard Legal Aid Bureau, 23 Everett Street #1, Cambridge, MA 02138.
Worker's Choice: A Way To Make Sure We Don't Undo Right-To-Work
Monday, July 13, 2015
Hillary Clinton's Economic Intervention Agenda Unveiled
Saturday, July 11, 2015
Berkman study finds public broadband can succeed
A new report by the Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard University, “Holyoke: A Massachusetts Municipal Light Plant Seizes Internet Access Business Opportunities,” documents the success of a municipally-owned electric utility in providing Internet access services.
The case study, which was co-written by Berkman Fellow David Talbot, Waide Warner, Carolyn Anderson, Kira Hessekiel, and Daniel Dennis Jones, found that the broadband network created by Holyoke’s municipal utility has saved the city about $300,000 per year in Internet costs and has been profitable for five of the last 10 years.
Massachusetts has 41 such “munis” –- serving more than 900,000 people and thousands of businesses -– but only 10 are in the Internet access business as allowed by state law. The Holyoke Gas & Electric Department’s telecom division competes with Comcast and Charter and serves 300 business customers and numerous public buildings. It has shown steady growth in revenues, and $500,000 in net earnings over the past decade. HG&E’s telecom division is also now providing a variety of services to three other municipalities. Finally, the utility is considering a residential high-speed Internet access offering, something the muni in neighboring Westfield is piloting later this year. HG&E’s success in a competitive environment was achieved without any debt issuance, tax, or subsidy from electricity or gas ratepayers.
Key Findings:
- HG&E Telecom saves city offices and HG&E itself more than $300,000 a year by providing Internet access and networking and telephone services to public agencies.
- The utility provides approximately 300 businesses and large institutions with telecom services and creates competition, which tends to improve service offerings from all market participants, aiding the local economy.
- HG&E Telecom forged inter-municipal agreements that extend services and accompanying benefits to the neighboring city of Chicopee and to the city of Greenfield, 30 miles north.
- While HG&E Telecom has focused on selling services to businesses, the utility is now considering a residential fiber-to-the-home (FTTH) offering, given the declining market pressure to provide television content.
- Demonstrating that a municipal light plant can diversify into the consultancy business, HG&E Telecom also recently became project and network manager for a FTTH project in the town of Leverett.
- HG&E Telecom has shown steady growth in the face of competition, never incurred debt, and has reaped a 10 percent profit in both 2013 and 2014.
Thursday, July 9, 2015
Crony Capitalism And The Growth Of Federal Regulation
Undisguised Value: Daniel Halperin has shaped U.S. tax policy and practitioners for more than a half-century
Credit: Kathleen Dooher
On July 1, Harvard Law School Professor Daniel I. Halperin retired after nearly 40 years as a law professor, including two decades as the Stanley S. Surrey Professor of Law at HLS. Below, reprinted from the Spring 2015 issue of the Harvard Law Bulletin, is a tribute to Halperin written by his colleague Alvin C. Warren, who is the Ropes & Gray Professor of Law at HLS.
Daniel I. Halperin ’61 retired at the end of this academic year after more than a half-century as a tax lawyer, professor and government official. Unlike most law professors starting out today, Dan worked as a lawyer for a decade—at the firm Kaye Scholer and in the government—before entering law teaching. Serendipitously, he became Kaye Scholer’s expert in the new field of pension law in his second year, after the sudden departure of the only lawyer at the firm with any experience in the field.
In 1967, Dan moved to Washington to join the staff of the Treasury Department’s Office of Tax Policy, which is the executive branch office responsible for tax regulations and legislative proposals. At the time, the assistant secretary of the Treasury for tax policy was Stanley S. Surrey, a legendary Harvard Law School professor who served as the principal tax policy officer for Presidents Kennedy and Johnson. (He had also been Dan’s teacher in a course on the taxation of international income.)
Although tax law is frequently contested and often political, Surrey’s rule was that his staff was to consider only the criteria of good tax policy in developing regulations and legislative proposals. Political issues were to be left to him, the Treasury secretary and the White House.
Dan flourished in this environment. Thanks to his practice experience, he played a key role in the development of the Johnson administration’s initial bill for pension security, which would evolve into the historic Employee Retirement Income Security Act, enacted by Congress in 1974.
Surrey further believed that the Treasury should not only focus on current regulatory and legislative issues, but also analyze and produce proposals for long-term reform. Dan played an important role in the evolution of these proposals, which eventually led to the Tax Reform Act of 1969. Although a lifelong Democrat, he remained at the Treasury as deputy tax legislative counsel after the election of President Nixon in order to see the proposals through to enactment.
Stimulated by his work at Treasury, Dan joined the faculty at the University of Pennsylvania Law School in 1970. His first major article as a professor, “Business Deduction for Personal Living Expenses: A Uniform Approach to an Unsolved Problem,” 122 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 859 (1974), remains a classic 40 years later.
In the presidential campaign of 1976, Jimmy Carter famously called the U.S. income tax system a “disgrace to the human race.” After the election of President Carter, Dan returned to the Treasury, first as tax legislative counsel and then as deputy assistant secretary. In those positions, he was instrumental in the formulation of the president’s 1978 tax reform proposals, some of which were enacted in the bipartisan Tax Reform Act of 1986.
In 1981, Dan returned to law teaching, this time at Georgetown, where he would remain for 15 years. He also returned to practice as a consultant for Ropes & Gray. It was during this period that Dan’s most famous article, “Interest in Disguise: Taxing the Time Value of Money,” 95 Yale Law Journal 506 (1986), appeared. Stemming from problems he had dealt with at Treasury, this article remains the seminal analysis of a series of issues that are still not fully resolved.
In 1996, Dan was appointed the first Stanley S. Surrey Professor of Law at Harvard Law School. Over the past 19 years, he has continued to write about tax law and policy, and has taught a variety of tax-related courses, covering income taxation, tax policy, pension law, and nonprofit organizations.
Throughout his long career, Dan has always been known in the tax law community for two attributes: his analytical sophistication and his generosity. No matter how difficult the problem, Dan is usually the first to see a solution (or why a solution may be impossible). This sophistication has always been coupled with remarkable generosity. When congressional staffers, young law professors or law students have asked for his help in understanding some difficult question, Dan has never been too busy to provide the requested assistance.
What are his plans for retirement? Dan has already begun work on a book on some unresolved issues in tax law and policy. Stanley Surrey would be proud.
Alvin Warren is Ropes & Gray Professor of Law at HLS, where he has taught tax law and policy since 1979.