Tuesday, March 15, 2016

Suk challenges graduating students to challenge the law and change the world

Professor Jeannie Suk imparts final words of wisdom to the graduating class as part of the Last Lecture series. The event was held Austin Hall.

Credit: Heratch Photography Professor Jeannie Suk offers words of wisdom to the graduating class as part of the ‘Last Lecture’ series, organized each year by the Class Marshals. The series features professors



“You have contributed so much to this school, and I sincerely hope that we have done you more good than harm,” Professor Jeannie Suk told the audience on February 29, as she kicked off the “Last Lecture Series” for the Harvard Law School Class of 2016. Organized by the Class Marshals, the series asks popular HLS professors to give a lecture as if it were their last opportunity to address the graduating class. Professors Annette Gordon-Reed, Robert Sitkoff, and Robert Bordone ‘97 will round out the rest of the four-part series in lectures later in the semester.


Joking that colleagues who saw the advertisement for her Last Lecture have asked if she has a terminal illness or is leaving to teach at Stanford, Suk said, “The reality is, I am going to die in this job, but hopefully not for a very long time. And from here I will experience vicariously, and with pride, the things that you all are doing to live greatly and contribute to our world.”


Suk began the lecture by sharing how her background has shaped her academic interests. “Many of you know that I don’t allow personal narratives in my classes, but one of the class marshals told me that I have to do some personal narrative in this lecture,” Suk said. She described her family’s harrowing escape from North Korea to South Korea during the Korean War. “It is possible that because trauma infused my family so deeply—my family’s entire existence was shaped by it during my childhood—that in my scholarly career, I became so fascinated with the phenomenon of trauma, of its uses and its abuses, its meanings and its consequences.”



Her family’s background also inspired her to study “the related concept of home,” Suk said. She characterized as “the most formative experience of [her] life” the challenges she faced when she first moved to Queens as an immigrant schoolchild with little knowledge of English, a problem compounded by the fact that her traditional parents discouraged her from speaking at home.


The experience of finding her voice has been a strong influence on her approach to learning and teaching, she said, and she still accesses those memories of disconnection to teach others “who don’t have voice” to be “fluent” in communicating with each other and the world. “To be connected to others—through language, and in the face of fear—has been a guiding principle in my life as a teacher,” she said.


Impeccable technique,” skills, and even artistry are not enough, Suk said. “You must challenge the way things are, and imagine a world that is better, and require a way of doing law that is better.



Invoking the words of George Balanchine, the founder of the School of American Ballet (SAB), Suk described education as essential for change. Suk, who attend the SAB, said that when asked to establish a ballet tradition in the United States, Balanchine was reported to have responded, “But first, a school.”


“A school is the foundation for society, its practices and its norms, and its aspirations,” Suk said. “In the classroom, I have tried to teach you the awesome responsibility and power you will have as some of the most influential legal actors in the world. You are people who will change our world, who will evolve the way we think and change this world’s future.”


Jeannie Suk

Credit: Heratch Photography ‘You have contributed so much to this school, and I sincerely hope that we have done you more good than harm,’ Professor Jeannie Suk told the audience on February 29, as she kicked off the Class of 2016’s ‘Last Lecture’ series. The series is arranged by each year’s Class Marshals to provide an opportunity for 3L and LL.M. students to hear about life after law school from notable HLS professors.



“Impeccable technique,” skills, and even artistry are not enough, Suk said. “You must challenge the way things are, and imagine a world that is better, and require a way of doing law that is better.”


Legal education is not a credential or a pedigree, but a “profound intellectual and socializing process,” she said.


“If you haven’t had the experience of doubting first principles, being provoked and disturbed, and angered—we haven’t done our job here. If you haven’t dissected the structures of power, authority, and legitimacy, and meaning that underlie our society—we have not done our job here,” Suk said. “The ability to do that is what makes the job of a lawyer so fundamental in our society. And rather than teach you what the law is, we should be teaching you how to think about problems that don’t have answers yet.”


Suk warned against merely falling back on “mimicry or repetition.” Students may look up to their professors, “but there’s a reason we teach you through questions, not answers.”


The most upsetting moments for her as a teacher, Suk said, often occur in the second semester of the first year, “when you ask a student, ‘is this a just result?’ and they don’t know what to say. Or ‘what is at stake in this case?’ Or ‘what should the law be?’ Or ‘what is the morality of this position that you see represented?’”


“When a student just answers these questions by pointing me to words in a case or previous cases, then I know that there’s something about the way our first-year education works that is not quite right.”


“It’s not an exaggeration to say that our law school is directly connected to the heart of this society, and I’m going to press you on your responsibility to serve the world and to question it and to change it,” Suk said.


“Students are what make this school’s aspirations real,” and Suk said this class is graduating into “a world on fire.” She credited the Class of 2016 with living its legal education “in true counterpoint with the social problems and social injustices surrounding us, problems that fundamentally indict our law and call for critique of the way that you have been taught to think here in these halls.”


“You have pushed this faculty to think harder and do better,” Suk said. She described how this graduating class has helped the faculty see that there is “no excuse for not exposing and confronting law’s role in creating and bolstering the very problems of inequality, of life and death, that have moved you to action in the past several years.”


In the closing minutes of her lecture, Suk gave advice based on lessons she has learned over the years. She said she was “liberated” by the process of giving up her “perfection complex” as a young professor—a process helped along by an incident where, as she was rushing to class, she fell on her face in front of a lecture hall full of students.


“I have made peace with being criticized and disagreed with,” by realizing that “not everybody’s going to love you; not everybody’s going to think you’re good.” It is most important to “listen to your heart in looking for and engaging in work that you love to do,” she said.


“You should accept your needs. And don’t feel badly about fulfilling them. I need to get eight hours of sleep a night,” Suk said. “I probably would’ve written a lot more and been more productive if I only needed six hours—but I need eight, and I take eight hours.”


Noting that she buys herself flowers when she finishes writing something, Suk reminded the audience to “give yourself rewards when you meet certain goals.”


Finally, “since no speech by a Korean law professor would be complete without an Irish blessing,” Suk said, to laughs in the audience: “May the road rise to meet you, may the wind be always at your back, may the sun shine warm upon your face, and rains fall soft upon your fields, and until we meet again, may God hold you in the palm of His hand.”

Monday, March 14, 2016

Harvard Corporation agrees to retire HLS shield

The Harvard Corporation has approved the recommendation of the Harvard Law School Shield Committee to retire the HLS shield, which is modeled on the family crest of an 18th century slaveholder.


“The Corporation agrees with your judgment and the recommendation of the committee that the Law School should have the opportunity to retire its existing shield and propose a new one,” wrote Harvard President Drew Faust and Senior Fellow William F. Lee in a March 14 letter to HLS Dean Martha Minow.


They also wrote that with the HLS bicentennial approaching in 2017, “we believe the School should have the opportunity to propose a new shield, that in the report’s word’s ‘more closely represent[s] the values of the Law School’ – one conducive to unifying the Law School community rather that dividing it.”


In a message to the HLS community announcing the corporation’s decision, Minow wrote: “The opportunity to consider a new symbol on the threshold of our Bicentennial allows us to engage in a productive and creative focus on expressing the School’s mission and values as we continue to strengthen its dedication to intellectual rigor and truth, to reasoned discourse and diverse views, and to a community marked by mutual respect and inclusiveness. Our constant efforts to marshal talent to serve justice and to advance human freedom and welfare are the best way to symbolize the ideals of Harvard Law School. 


“We cannot choose our history but we can choose that for which we stand. Above all, we rededicate ourselves to the hard work of eradicating not just symbols of injustice but injustice itself,” she wrote.


The shield is modeled on the coat of arms of the family of Isaac Royall, whose bequest endowed the first professorship of law at Harvard. Royall was the son of an Antiguan slaveholder. In 1936, the Harvard Corporation and Radcliffe Trustees adopted seals for 27 Harvard academic units, naming the Royall crest, with its three sheaths of wheat, as the Law School shield.


Because of its ties to slave labor, the shield came under fire in October, when a group of law school students formed an organization called “Royall Must Fall” to demand that HLS discontinue using the Royall family crest as its symbol.


In November, Dean Minow appointed a committee of faculty, students, alumni and staff to evaluate whether HLS should continue using the shield. The committee included: Bruce Mann, Carl F. Schipper, Jr. Professor of Law, chaired the shield committee, which also included legal historians Tomiko Brown-Nagin, Annette Gordon-Reed and Samuel Moyn, as well as Janet Halley, who holds the Royall Professorship of Law at HLS and has written about the legacy of the Royall family and the slaves of the Royall household. Alumnus Jim Bowers ’70, senior counsel at Day Pitney and a member of the Senior Advisory Council of the Harvard Law School Association, also served on the committee, along with Robert Katz ’72, chair of the Dean’s Advisory Board and former general counsel of Goldman Sachs. Also on the committee were three students appointed by the student government, Mawuse H. Vormawor LL.M. ’16, Rena Karefa-Johnson ’16 and Annie Rittgers ’17. The staff representatives were S. Darrick Northington and Yih-hsien Shen ’95.


The committee issued its report recommending to the corporation that HLS abandon the shield on March 3. Two members of the group —Professor Gordon-Reed and law student Rittgers —submitted “A Different View,” arguing that the law school should maintain the current shield, “tying it to a historically sound interpretative narrative about it.”


In its March 14 letter, Faust and Lee expressed appreciation for the main committee report and the separate opinion, as well as the work of the wider HLS community that joined in the process and discussion. They said they agreed with the committee’s view that “modern institutions must acknowledge their past associations with slavery, not to assign guilt, but to understand the pervasiveness of the legacy of slavery and its continuing impact on the world in which we live.”


The corporation emphasized that, while they accepted the request to change the shield, “we do so on the understanding the School will actively explore other steps to recognize rather than to suppress the realities of its history, mindful of our shared obligation to honor the past not by seeking to erase it, but rather by bringing it to light and learning from it.”


 

Friday, March 11, 2016

At Harvard Law School symposium, military and academic leaders explain legal and cultural issues in counterterror operations

Harvard Law School Lecturer on Law Bonnie Docherty and John Fitzpatrick ’87, HLS Clinical Instructor and a major in the US Army Reserve Judge Advocate General's (JAG) Corps. Docherty teaches in the International Human Rights Clinic and is an expert on disarmament and international humanitarian law. Fitzpatrick is a supervising attorney at Harvard Prison Legal Assistance Project and a senior clinical instructor.

John Fitzpatrick ’87, HLS Clinical Instructor and a major in the US Army Reserve Judge Advocate General’s (JAG) Corps with Harvard Law School Lecturer on Law Bonnie Docherty, at the Legal, Cultural and Strategic Issues in Counterterror Operations Symposium, at HLS on March 5.



On March 5, Harvard Law School hosted the first-ever Legal, Cultural and Strategic Issues in Counterterror Operations Symposium bringing together military officers from the 3rd Legal Operations Detachment and academic scholars whose work focuses on areas of Islamic and human rights law as well as on cultural and international security issues.


More than 30 military personnel from the U.S. Army, Air Force, and Navy attended the daylong symposium, which featured presentations by faculty from Harvard Law School, Harvard Kennedy School, Boston University and Tufts. Presentations focused on the effects of war on civilian populations in areas of armed conflict; the sources and representative doctrines in Islamic family and domestic relations law; and the cultural, political, and legal issues impacting current operations in Afghanistan.


The symposium was organized by John Fitzpatrick ’87, a senior clinical instructor at HLS, with assistance from Staff Sergeant Derek Piatt of the Army’s 3rd Legal Operations Detachment.


Gobourne-km.rev

More than 30 military personnel from the U.S. Army, Air Force, and Navy attended the daylong symposium.



A Major in the US Army Reserve Judge Advocate General’s (JAG) Corps, Fitzpatrick took a leave of absence from HLS in 2013 to deploy for an active duty tour in Afghanistan.  He said he was motivated to organize the program because he believes there is a significant gap between Army JAG training and the relevant research being done in academia. “Given the increasing challenges we face in our operations around the world, we are missing a valuable opportunity if we don’t do everything we can to bridge this gap,” he said.


Senior Clinical Instructor and Lecturer on Law Bonnie Docherty, who teaches in the International Human Rights Clinic and is an expert on disarmament and international humanitarian law, gave a talk about her recent work, including extensive research on the law and ethics of next-generation fully autonomous (robotic) weapons systems; and a soon to be released report on legal challenges involved in the US military’s current use of the hostile intent standard for use of lethal force.


Salma Mohsen Waheedi, an attorney and a visiting fellow in Middle Eastern Studies at Harvard’s Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, delivered an address focused on the sources and representative doctrines in Islamic family and domestic relations law, and the customs and traditions observed in Islamic households.


Thomas Barfield, an anthropology professor at Boston University and director of Boston University’s Institute for the Study of Muslim Societies & Civilization, and Emile Simpson, an Ernest May Fellow in History and Policy, International Security at Harvard University, discussed “Afghan History, Culture, and Politics and Law of War.” Barfield’s research focuses on problems of political development in Afghanistan, particularly on systems of local governance and dispute resolution. Simpson completed three tours in southern Afghanistan, from 2006–2012, as an infantry officer in the British Army. He wrote his first book, “War From the Ground Up: Twenty-First-Century Combat as Politics,” based on his experience in Afghanistan.


In her talk, “Civilians in Armed Conflict,” Dyan Mazurana, an associate professor and research director at the Feinstein International Center at The Fletcher School, Tufts University, provided an overview of her work with the United Nations, NGOs and governments on the effects of war on civilian populations in Afghanistan and other violence-plagued regions of the world.Group-km-rev


Fitzpatrick said he was “humbled” by the positive response he received from the attendees and participating faculty. One of the goals of the program, he said, was to overcome “a sense of mutual suspicion that can exist between the academic and military worlds.”


He said the takeaway message from the day-long event was: “We should not be afraid of knowledge, even if it that means hearing from perspectives we don’t agree with. More knowledge, and the free exchange of ideas on subjects of common interest, can only be to the mutual benefit of both our military and academic communities.”

Thursday, March 10, 2016

Focusing on law and the treatment of animals

What do Islamic law, direct democracy, and environmental law have in common? These topics were among the issues explored during Animal Law Week, a series of events hosted at Harvard Law School from February 15-21 by HLS’s Student Animal Legal Defense Fund (SALDF), the Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) and the Harvard Animal Law & Policy Program.


The weeklong series featured lunch talks by a range of animal law advocates and scholars. At the end of the week, students from law schools across the country participated in three days of National Animal Law Competitions.


Professor Kristen Stilt led the first lunch talk, entitled “The Women’s Movement, Animal Welfare, and Islamic Law: Constitutional Animal Protection in Egypt.” In addition to running Harvard’s new Animal Law & Policy Program, Stilt serves as co-director of the Islamic Legal Studies Program. Stilt created the “Animals, Law & Religion Project,” which studies how religious practices around the world affect animal welfare.





Making animals more visible to the law


Chris Green and Kristen Stilt in Austin Hall’s Ames courtroom with Lola, Stilt’s rescue dog from Egypt

Credit: Stu Rosner Chris Green and Kristen Stilt in Austin Hall’s Ames courtroom with Lola, Stilt’s rescue dog from Egypt



Harvard Magazine recently featured a story on the evolution of animal law in the United States, highlighting the new HLS Animal Law & Policy Program and faculty director Kristen Stilt. At the moment, says Stilt, the law remains unwavering: animals are property—albeit with certain protections. “It’s part of what makes this field fascinating,” she says. “We know how law doesn’t work for animals, but we have no clear idea yet about how it should.” Read Are Animals “Things”? at Harvard Magazine.




In another talk, David Wolfson, a partner at Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy, explained that while he specializes in corporate mergers and acquisitions, he has developed deep pro bono experience representing groups such as the Humane Society and Farm Sanctuary in administrative challenges, litigation, and legislation.



Wolfson spoke about how animal law reflects general trends in how modern social justice movements function. “It used to be when I was younger that you marched to Washington, you got a lot of people and you passed a federal law, and everything changed,” but that doesn’t happen anymore for a variety of reasons, Wolfson said, in part because activism has shifted to other tactics such as consumer pressure and social networking.


Another talk, on “Direct Democracy and Animal Protection,” featured discussion about animal protection ballot initiatives, led by Nancy Perry and Kelly Murray of the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA). Perry began by acknowledging how emotionally difficult it can be for people who care about animal welfare to become experts in animal suffering in order to be effective advocates.



“One way to feel better about all of the horrors that animals face is to be a part of making change for them,” Perry said. “Even if it’s incremental and even if it’s small, it does help allay the way that experiencing knowing about their suffering makes you feel.”


Later in the week, Ingrid Newkirk, President of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), spoke to a packed room about human obligations toward animal rights. Another talk focused on animal abuse prosecution and featured Niki Caferri of the Queens County Animal Cruelty Prosecutions Unit and Scott Heiser of the Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF).



In an afternoon event co-sponsored by the Harvard Environmental Law Review, Florida A&M University College of Law Professor Randall Abate discussed what animal law can learn from environmental law, ways in which the movements are different, and ideas for how the two movements can collaborate.


From Friday to Sunday, HLS students volunteered and participated in the National Animal Law Competitions (NALC), which were organized by the Lewis & Clark Law School’s Center for Animal Law Studies. The inter-law school event featured three categories of competition: appellate moot court, closing argument, and legislative drafting and lobbying.


 


 


Read More

In Winning Rights for Animals, Approaches Differ


The Harvard Law Record featured HLS 2L Daniel Sondike's analysis of Animal Law Week. "Winning rights for animals remains a daunting task, given danimal suffering’s unparalleled scale and the numerous political roadblocks," he wrote. "The speakers of Animal Law Week signified an uncertain, yet exciting, future for animal law." Read his full article here.





Animal Law Week came amid a steady rise of interest in and resources for animal law on Harvard’s campus. Animal rights study has existed at HLS since the Bob Barker Endowment for the Study of Animal Rights was established fourteen years ago, but a recent gift from the founder and president of the Animal Welfare Trust, Bradley Goldberg, has launched a new level of activity.


One year after Stilt joined the HLS faculty, the Animal Law & Policy Program under her direction is now in full swing. The Program—which is committed to facilitating scholarship, fostering discourse, and bridging theory and practice—introduced a new Wildlife Law class this past fall. Stilt is currently teaching a spring Animal Law class, and Wolfson, the Milbank partner, will teach an Animal Law class this fall.


One key feature of the Animal Law & Policy Program is its two-year, full-time residential fellowship. The Program’s first Academic Fellow, Delcianna Winders, began her term in August. Winders helped develop an Animal Law program at NYU Law School and she has published several scholarly works in the field.


Upcoming events sponsored by the Program include a comparative Workshop on Animals, Law, and Religion in May, as well as an academic conference on The Animal Welfare Act at Age Fifty in the early fall.

Just Say No To Nancy Reagan's 'Outspoken Intolerance'

“If you asked anyone in America today what Nancy Reagan does,” the first lady’s former press secretary, Sheila Tate, told the Associated Press in 1986, “they’d say she was involved in fighting drugs. She owns that issue now….It’s what she’ll be remembered for.” Tate surely was right about that. Lady Bird [...]

Tuesday, March 8, 2016

Corporate Inversions Are The Symptoms, Bad Tax Policy Is The Disease

Attempts to punish companies that are pursuing corporate inversions misdiagnose the problem and, in so doing, make a bad situation worse.

Monday, March 7, 2016

Four Months After Criminal Charge Was Dropped, Illinois Man Finally Wins Back His Seized Truck

Bart Johnson’s bizarre case highlights the injustice of civil forfeiture laws, which don’t require criminal convictions or even charges before letting police permanently take property.