Thursday, April 7, 2016

Students spend spring break focused on legal services work

Each year, teams of Harvard Law School students are given the opportunity to spend their Spring Break experiencing legal services work with clinics and legal organizations in the Boston area, or working on projects around the country and abroad. These trips and placements are part of an “alternative spring break” program developed and sponsored by the Office of Clinical and Pro Bono programs at Harvard Law School.


This year, during the week of March 11-18, students worked locally at the Volunteer Lawyers Project of the Boston Bar Association; at Greater Boston Legal Services (GBLS)/Legal Advocacy and Resource Center (LARC); and at the law school's own Legal Services Center (LSC)/Veterans Legal Clinic.


Project teams traveled within the U.S. and abroad, working with Equal Justice Under Law in Murfressboro, TN, following up on the work of last year's pro bono trip to Tennessee by contributing to a civil rights lawsuit, Rodriguez v. PCC, that resulted from that work; assisting with litigation to advance human rights protections for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and intersex (LGBTI) Ugandans under the supervision of lawyers at the Human Rights Awareness and Promotion Forum (HRAPF); at the newly established Crossroads Cultural Arts Center (CCAC) in Clarksdale, MS with the goal to promote local artists and to use art as a tool for community connection and reconciliation; and at ProBAR in Harlingen, TX, at the Adult Legal Orientation Program, engaging in direct client representation. This is the 12th year that the Office of Clinical and Pro Bono Programs has funded the trips, which originated in response to Hurricane Katrina in 2005, when students went to New Orleans to assist displaced families.


Here, a few students share their accounts, reflecting on the significance of their service.


***


Human rights litigation in Uganda


Brian Klosterboer '16


L-R: Maithreyi Nandagopalan '18, Charles Fletcher '18, Brandon Storm '18, Anna Crowe, Clinical Fellow in the International Human Rights Clinic, Brian Klosterboer '16, and Andres Caicedo '16 pictured at the Human Rights Awareness and Promotion Forum (HRAPF)

L-R: Maithreyi Nandagopalan '18, Charles Fletcher '18, Brandon Storm '18, Clinical Fellow in the International Human Rights Clinic Anna Crowe, Brian Klosterboer '16, and Andres Caicedo '16. at the Human Rights Awareness and Promotion Forum (HRAPF).



Five students traveled to Uganda over spring break to work on pending litigation that could advance human rights protections for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and intersex (LGBTI) Ugandans. LGBTI rights have been a contentious issue in Uganda since 2007, when LGBTI Ugandans started advocating publicly for their rights. This sparked backlash from pastors and politicians with close ties to the United States, and in 2009 a Member of Parliament proposed the death penalty for “serial offenders” of homosexuality. The death penalty was later reduced to life imprisonment, and a number of court battles over LGBTI rights ensued.


The students from Harvard worked under the supervision of lawyers at the Human Rights Awareness and Promotion Forum (HRAPF), a nongovernmental organization in Kampala that provides direct services, conducts research and advocacy, and coordinates strategic litigation. During the week-long trip, the team conducted legal research, met with lawyers and activists, and wrote an internal memo. Organized by Lambda at Harvard Law and Harvard Law Student Advocates for Human Rights, the trip included Andres Caicedo '16, Brandon Storm '18, Brian Klosterboer '16, Charlie Fletcher '18, and Mitha Nandagopalan '18.


With the guidance of HRAPF attorneys, the team researched Ugandan and international law while exploring human rights strategies for advancing the rule of law. Since 2008, HRAPF has been a leader in promoting human rights for marginalized groups, including LGBTI individuals, sex workers, and women and children living with HIV.


In August 2014, HRAPF was lead counsel in a case that overturned Uganda's Anti-Homosexuality Act in the Constitutional Court. Brian Klosterboer '16 was part of that team as he interned at HRAPF during his 1L summer. Adrian Jjuuko, HRAPF's Executive Director, has also visited Harvard Law School twice as a speaker in the last three years.


HRAPF and Harvard strengthened these connections as students spent five days working with HRAPF attorneys and paralegals. The students also met with LGBTI clients and visited journalists and activists from the Kuchu Times Media Group (KTMG).


L-R: Maithreyi Nandagopalan '18, Charles Fletcher '18, Brandon Storm '18, Anna Crowe, Clinical Fellow in the International Human Rights Clinic, Brian Klosterboer '16, and Andres Caicedo '16 pictured at the Human Rights Awareness and Promotion Forum (HRAPF)

The team presents its final memo to Patricia Kimera, the Head of Access to Justice at HRAPF. In the photo from left to right around the table are Brandon Storm '18, Mitha Nandagopalan '18, Brian Klosterboer '16, Andres Caicedo '16, Patricia Kimera, and Nate Freeman, who is currently a fellow at HRAPF.



KTMG is an LGBTI-led media group that provides a platform for LGBTI Africans to share their stories in their own voices. It was founded in December 2014 by Kasha Jacqueline Nabagesera, who had previously been a plaintiff in a lawsuit against a Ugandan tabloid. That tabloid published the names, pictures, and addresses of dozens of LGBTI Ugandans and called for them to be killed. HRAPF represented Nabagesera in the case and set an important precedent that LGBTI individuals have the same right to privacy as everyone else.


Despite this ruling, Nabagesera and others continued to be outed and attacked in Ugandan tabloids. They decided to create a magazine and news website to tell their own narratives. Last Wednesday, students met with the staff of KTMG and saw a sneak peek of the second issue of Bombastic magazine, which is set to be released next week.


While in Uganda, the team also saw a cultural dance show, went white water rafting on the Nile River, and took a boat cruise on Lake Victoria. The team was welcomed by three LLMs–Godiva Akullo '15, Susan Mirembe '15, and David Lewis '15–who graduated from Harvard last year and are now lecturers of law at two leading universities in Kampala.


The memo that the team produced is confidential, but students hope that their research and analysis will contribute to HRAPF's mission of advancing human rights for all Ugandans.


The trip was sponsored by the Office of Clinical and Pro Bono Programs, and Anna Crowe, a fellow in the International Human Rights Clinic, joined students on the trip.


***


Providing a variety of legal services in greater Boston


Lydia Mwalimu Adude LL.M. '16


Christian Williams '17', Antuan Johnson '16, and Lydia Mwalimu Adude LL.M. '16 during a Boston City Housing public hearing at the Boston City Hall

From left: Christian Williams '17', Antuan Johnson '16, and Lydia Mwalimu Adude LL.M. '16 during a Boston City Housing public hearing at the Boston City Hall on a proposed Just Cause Eviction (JCE) ordinance, which seeks to incorporate safeguards for renters facing eviction and for small homeowners facing foreclosure of their homes in the Boston housing economy.



They say that the market is flooded with lawyers, but this does not really mean that the field of public interest is flooded. Public interest law is still in dire need of lawyers. Accordingly, my main driving force in taking part in the spring pro bono projects was because it presented an opportunity for me to give back to society with my already acquired legal skills, and equally to get more acquainted with the U.S. legal system.


I worked with Greater Boston Legal Services (GBLS) and the Legal Advocacy & Resource Center (LARC). I worked with LARC screening clients for intake in a number of areas, including bankruptcy law. I also worked on a lawyer for the day project by conducting online research and telephone inquiries on the lawyer for the day programs and other pro se resources in probate and family courts in Massachusetts. I assisted the GBLS Criminal Offender Record Information (CORI) Sealing Unit in its legal representation of clients at the Roxbury Trial Court, and visited the Massachusetts State House to help create awareness on a Senate Bill, SB 2176, passed by the Massachusetts Senate on March 10, 2016 to increase the felony larceny threshold from the current $250 to $1500. My presence at GBLS also presented an opportunity to attend the Boston City Housing public hearing on the proposed Just Cause Eviction (JCE) ordinance. JCE seeks to incorporate safeguards for renters facing eviction and small home owners facing foreclosure of their homes in the Boston housing economy.


Greater Boston Legal Services teamI was hesitant at first because of my foreign legal education but I am glad that I was able to fit in nicely so fast through the guidance of my supervisors. What surprised me most was the diverse pool of people seeking legal aid in order to access justice, and the fact that the limitations on the legal services field meant that most of them had to be turned away even though the organization tried its best to make external referrals. The spring break pro bono project exposed me to the intricacies of the legal services sector in the U.S., and the diverse nature of the U.S. populace. All in all it gives me great pleasure to know that my pro bono legal service made justice accessible to someone in need of legal aid.


***


Navigating the border: A dispatch from ProBAR in Texas


Edith Sangueza '18


Seen from the outside, the Port Isabel Detention Center (PIDC) is a cheerful coral color, with an asymmetrical glass front. Palm trees and bougainvillea flowers line the well-kept grounds. A short distance away, spring breakers enjoy the beaches and beer on South Padre Island.


On the inside, though, the detention center is chilly, sterile, and unmistakably prison-like. To the more than one thousand people detained inside, it might as well be prison. Detainees, often fleeing extreme violence in their home countries in Central America, eastern Africa, and South Asia, have no right to counsel in navigating the U.S.'s byzantine immigration laws. ProBAR, a legal aid organization based in nearby Harlingen, steps in to fill the gaps, helping detainees prepare for their cases. Because of strictures from its funding model, ProBAR chiefly provides legal education and helps people so they are better prepared to represent themselves pro se.


We arrived at ProBAR on Monday and received a brief orientation from Edgar GaucĂ­n, the office manager, whose own life has spanned the border from Matamoros, Mexico, to Brownsville, TX. Once oriented, we headed out to PIDC where we split up and were able to interview several people seeking asylum. We helped them prepare English-language versions of their I-589 forms, the form potential asylees must prepare in order to apply for either asylum or for withholding of removal. We talked to people with a wide range of ages, experiences, and motivations for leaving their home countries, including some whose past criminal records could be serious obstacles to their asylum applications.


The experience was incredibly valuable as a way to see what the asylum process is like in practice, especially within the expedited removal context. It was also re-centering and motivating as a way to put my legal education into practice.


***


A memorable experience with Volunteer Lawyers Project


Lan Jiangshou LL.M. '16


I am very grateful to have spent my spring break at Volunteer Lawyers Project (VLP). I never imagined how this pro bono experience could help me in a way that is so tangible and memorable. I crafted my skills by attending the Boston Housing Court, the Boston Municipal Court, the Quincy Small Claims Court and the Suffolk Family Court; by participating in the trainings and luncheons organized by the VLP; and by interacting directly with the clients at different clinics on bankruptcy law, consumer law, guardianship law, family law and housing law. Moreover, as someone with a legal background from China, this five-day experience gave me the precious opportunity to see how the pro bono system in the U.S. is funded and operated, and the breadth and impact of the system in the communities.


My eyes were opened to substantive law areas that I have not encountered–and would not encounter–in the big law firms. During my spring break, I was introduced to a unique group of people who were energetic and incentivized, cautiously balancing the two requirements of their job: keeping a sympathetic and empathetic eye on the clients and avoiding a quick emotional burn-out. I was able to glance at a previously neglected world, which is out there, vibrant and real. I would not be exaggerating when saying that pro bono work can nourish one's soul. By handling every individual case, we drag one person or a household out of desperation. We redefine ourselves in paving the way to justice, and in aggregation naturally assume the role of fixing the systematic problems inherent in our society that I have eye-witnessed for the past five days and could not, from then on, just stand by.

Dallas Wants To Destroy A Popular Small Business--And Not Pay Him A Dime

Instead of respecting the property rights of minority-owned businesses, the city wants to redevelop and gentrify the area.

Wednesday, April 6, 2016

Protecting Our Semi-Privacy After The Department Of Justice Apple iPhone Hack

The Department of Justice-sponsored unlocking of the Apple iPhone used by one of the San Bernardino murderers without Apple's help reaffirmed that an overly encryption-based cybersecurity emphasis remains misdirected. It's always been true that “getting to unbreakable is impossible,” as Apple now says. Until the hack, debate among cyber-libertarians and law-and-order [...]

Annette Gordon-Reed on making a contribution to historiography

Professor Annette Gordon-Reed '84 spoke about her experiences combining legal analysis and historical research at a March 9 event hosted by the Class Marshals as part of the Last Lecture Series. This year's series, which invites HLS professors to give a lecture as if addressing the graduating class for the last time, also features Jeannie Suk '02, Robert Sitkoff, and Robert Bordone '97.


Gordon-Reed, who has received the National Book Award and the Pulitzer Prize in History, specializes in American legal history. She is the Carol K. Pforzheimer Professor at the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study, the Charles Warren Professor of American Legal History at Harvard Law School, and a Professor of History at Harvard University.


Professor Annette Gordon-Reed '84.

Credit: Asia Kepka Professor Annette Gordon-Reed '84.



Gordon-Reed began her talk by crediting her parents with teaching her to think of herself as “a privileged person.” Acknowledging that “privilege” has taken on a negative connotation of “cluelessness” about power, Gordon-Reed explained her parents' message was that privilege created a duty to make the world a better place.


She did not mean “material privilege,” Gordon-Reed clarified. She spoke of how her parents, a teacher and a soft-hearted businessman, were not wealthy but were privileged in the sense that “they had had experiences that told them there was a lot more out there in the world.”


Gordon-Reed shared how, when it came time for her to start school, her African-American parents defied expectations and sent her to “the white school.” Texas was still deeply divided at the time, ten years after the Brown decision desegregating public schools, and six-year-old Gordon-Reed had to go to the elementary school by herself. “Talk about hostile environments,” she said with a chuckle.


“It was a difficult time, but at that moment, this was an early sort of introduction to the idea that law mattered,” she said. “It was something that my parents talked about; it was something that had operation in my life.”


At the movies, her family sat in a different balcony, and at the doctor's office, they had to sit in a separate waiting room, Gordon-Reed recalled. In that doctor's waiting room, she would look through the glass window to the other side and see that the other side had magazines.


“I knew that law sort of came along and eventually changed all of this. Laws put this in place, but lawyers working in another way could change that. And they transformed my community and my parents' life,” Gordon-Reed said.


She was interested in history and writing from early on, she said, but it was her father who suggested that she consider studying law. Gordon-Reed initially started at HLS “to change the world,” but her plans shifted as she realized certain legal jobs could command salaries that were “way out of proportion with what anybody in my family would have made.”


“I started to think, 'Is it really practical for me to give that up for what I wanted to do-to be a writer?'” Consoling herself that she could do both-practice law and write on the side-she joined a large law firm, where she quickly found that there was no time to write.


Gordon-Reed said she was grateful for the learning opportunities at the firm, but she knew it was not the kind of work she wanted to do. Her feeling that she would not stay long at the firm was intensified, she said, by the fact colleagues frequently could not tell her apart from two other African-American women at the firm, one of whom was Loretta Lynch '84, now U.S. Attorney General.


Gordon-Reed described how she became serious about pursuing her original dreams of writing after someone handed her a copy of a newspaper op-ed by one of her college classmates. “Envy is one of the deadly sins, but it can also be a great catalyst,” she said. She remembered thinking, “If this person can be in the New York Times, writing, and he leaves a lot to be desired, I can do this. I can definitely do this, and I should do this, and I should not waste my time.”


There are other people who are much better at and love practicing law, including her husband, Gordon-Reed said. “But that was not for me. That's not what I wanted to do. I wanted to write; I wanted to do research; I wanted to enter the lives of other people but to do it in the way that I wanted to do it.”


She left her law firm job and spent several years as general counsel for the New York City Board of Corrections, but looking at murals painted by the inmates left her in tears at the sense of wasted talent. “I went in happy that I was going to be able to make a difference, but it was just too much,” Gordon-Reed said.


The city agency job did have the upside of giving her more time for writing, and she finally decided to enter academia. She felt, she said, that moment “was the only shot I had to be able to write, to be able to think about issues, to be able to use all of the things that I had been thinking about up to this moment-to be thinking about society, to be writing about society in a way that I thought would be useful.”


In the course of her research and writing, Gordon-Reed became interested in a little-known movie called Jefferson in Paris, which touched on Thomas Jefferson's relationship with his slave Sally Hemings. Critics were using pseudo-legal language such as whether the story could be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and Gordon-Reed realized that as a lawyer with a preexisting interest in Jefferson and the history of slavery, she had important things to say about this topic.


Her research was not driven by the question of whether Jefferson and Hemings had been involved. Rather, “what interested me was how law and how white supremacy was used in history to deal with this topic, to debunk this story,” she said.


Gordon-Reed explained the key points that stood out to her about the story. First, slaves could testify against free black people but not against white people, and second, slaves could not legally marry. By de-legitimating black people and black families, the slavery system used legal rules to diminish black people as untrustworthy, she explained. “Whether Tom and Sally had children or not was interesting, but it was really how historians were writing about it, and how they wrote black people out of the story.”


Gordon-Reed published two books on the topic, Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings: An American Controversy in 1997 and The Hemingses of Monticello: An American Family in 2008. Eventually DNA testing vindicated her research by proving the Hemings family descended from Jefferson.


Gordon-Reed recalled the excitement of that time. “I got to be a writer, I got to be a researcher, I got to look at a topic that I was passionate about, and I think I was able to make a contribution to historiography, sort of changing the way people think about Jefferson, an important figure who was quite controversial in a lot of ways but who also looms large over American history,” she said.


Ultimately, her work stems from the way her parents taught her to think about herself, Gordon-Reed said. “The Hemingses of Monticello continues with the notion that I wanted to break-to sort of relieve-enslaved families from the grip of law.”


“Law is important. Obviously I believe that. But the kinds of human relations, the kinds of things we're talking about in both of these books, transcend it,” Gordon-Reed said. “Sometimes you have to look beyond it, because the law is not put in place for everybody, is not made to work for everybody. It's our hope that we can try to make it work for everybody, but the historian understands that there are moments when that just was not the case, and slavery was one of them.”

Tuesday, April 5, 2016

SCOTUS Ruling Actually Means 'One Person One Vote' Lives To Fight Another Day

The best that the plaintiffs could ever have hoped for was a ruling upholding the Texas' position that the states can use CVAP but are not required to,

Monday, April 4, 2016

Former national security adviser Juan Zarate on money laundering in real estate industry

Summer 2009Not long ago, only bold-faced financiers and business tycoons would even think of plunking down cash for a $10 million beachfront penthouse or a $25 million pied-a-terre overlooking New York City's Central Park. Thanks to a luxury real estate boom, lots of high-end properties are being sold today, but to whom has become a shadowy question.


Seeking to end that practice, the U.S. Treasury Department's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) launched a six-month temporary initiative in March to pierce the veil of secrecy that often shrouds luxury real estate sales involving all-cash buyers in New York City and the Miami area.


For the first time, title insurance companies will be obligated to discover and disclose the identity of an actual person, or “beneficial owner,” behind any legal entity, usually a limited liability corporation (LLC), used in a residential transaction. That information will become part of a database that will be available to law enforcement investigators.


Such purchases, made using shell companies that conceal the identity of those involved as well as the source of their cash, are often favored by foreign buyers and now constitute half of the home sales of $5 million and up nationwide, according to a 2015 expose in The New York Times. In New York City and Los Angeles, that number is even higher.


Some analysts suspect that the widespread use of LLCs or other opaque vehicles, which can be enmeshed in an international shell company network that is difficult for law enforcement to untangle, facilitates money laundering or those looking to keep ill-gotten gains out of the reach of government authorities, suspicious relatives, and others.


Although granted broad powers under the USA Patriot Act of 2001 to institute and enforce anti-money-laundering measures in a variety of industries, including banking, mortgage, insurance, and real estate, the Treasury Department has not required those involved in real estate closings, such as title companies, real estate and escrow agents, or lawyers, to ascertain or report who profits from the purchase and sale of properties.


Juan Carlos Zarate '93, J.D. '97, is a visiting lecturer of law at Harvard Law School, a former deputy national security adviser in the George W. Bush administration, and a former assistant secretary of the U.S. Treasury for terrorist financing and financial crimes. The Gazette spoke with Zarate about the scope of the problem and what this new oversight might portend.


GAZETTE: How pervasive is money laundering in the U.S. today, and how much is tangled up in real estate?


ZARATE: The concern over high volumes of illicit capital flowing in and through the United States, especially in the real estate market, is real. The reason for FinCEN's GTO [geographic targeting order] is precisely to get more data around what may be happening in terms of real estate investments and money laundering. The concern is the use of front companies and shell corporations to invest large amounts of money in high-end properties as a way of hiding or layering illicit funds. The two markets targeted by FinCEN's rule - New York and Miami - have seen an increase not just in foreign purchases of high-end property, but also a high percentage of that happening through front companies and shell corporations. When you look at the Manhattan market, some of it is coming from Russia and China, and in Miami from sources like Venezuela and other places where you have inherent risk.


So the fact-gathering is an attempt to get a handle on what may be the movement of illicit financing into the real estate markets and the use of real estate as a high-volume money-laundering vehicle in the U.S. To your broader question, globally, money laundering represents an extremely significant challenge for authorities, to the tune of billions of dollars of illicit capital. Money laundering, of course, is the attempt to hide, layer, and place illicit funds and ill-gotten gains, to make those proceeds look legitimate, and to find ways to place them or layer them back into the economy. That happens in all sorts of ways, and it can happen through the purchase of real estate.


GAZETTE: Who are these all-cash buyers? And aside from Manhattan and Miami-Dade, where else is it a problem?


ZARATE: Buyers come from all sorts of countries and places. There's been concern, for example, in the New York market that you have a predominance of Russian- and Chinese-sourced purchases and questions as to who are the beneficial owners of those properties, and in particular the shell corporations - who or what is behind those purchases. The same goes for Miami. But in Miami, it's not just Russian money, but also money coming out of Latin America, in particular places like Venezuela. Any place you have high-value property and the ability of foreign investors to find attractive investment opportunities because of new development, because of markets opening up, because of the likely increased value of property as a way of retaining and gaining value, you're likely to see foreign investment. Certainly you've seen that in the Los Angeles and Southern California real estate market, and I think the same goes for Northern California around the San Francisco/San Jose area. There's no question that FinCEN's focus on New York and Miami is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of their attempts to understand what's happening in the United States … that will no doubt take them to other cities and geographies.


 



Read More

From the Summer 2014 issue of the Harvard Law Bulletin



“Treasury's War: The Unleashing of a New Era of Financial Warfare,” by Juan C. Zarate '97 (PublicAffairs)


treasurys-war-coverFollowing the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, the world's focus understandably turned to the U.S. military response. But in the aftermath of the attacks, the country also devised very different techniques to fight terrorists-techniques which Zarate writes have “increasingly become the national security tools of choice for the hard international security issues facing the United States.” The author should know, as one who served as the first assistant secretary of the Treasury for terrorist financing and financial crimes. In his book, Zarate, a lecturer on law at Harvard Law School and a senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, details the “hidden war” involving the expansion of the international anti-money laundering regime; financial tools and intelligence focused on national security; and a relationship with private-sector banks to help isolate rogue entities. Zarate also tells the story of his colleagues who have fought the financial war wearing gray suits instead of camo fatigues. In particular, he describes actions against regimes like Iran, North Korea, and Syria as well as nonstate actors like Al Qaeda, including locating and recovering Saddam Hussein's hidden assets in Iraq and abroad, and targeting a bank helping North Korea evade sanctions and conduct illicit financial activity. In addition, Zarate writes on the coming financial wars, including how the U.S. system may itself be vulnerable. Because the tools and strategies of financial warfare may be appropriated by others around the world, he writes, “The United States must begin to play a new and distinctly financial game of geopolitical competition to ensure its security and to seize emerging opportunities.”





GAZETTE: Why are so many more luxury properties acquired through shell companies today than, say, 10 or 20 years ago? And are there legitimate, lawful reasons for someone to hold property in a shell company?


ZARATE: Part of it is there's been an easing of the ability to create these vehicles in different jurisdictions and legal mechanisms - lawyers, accountants who specialize in this work - and the ability to create different corporate vehicles for all sorts of economic and financial purposes for transactions, including investment in real estate. Certainly there are legitimate uses where you have groups of investors involved, specific legitimate transactions facilitated, or you may have certain individuals who are worried about revealing their wealth or being harassed or even targeted by oppressive regimes, and so you can imagine situations where at least having a vehicle that hides the beneficial ownership, on first blush, or creates a useful investment vehicle is helpful to some legitimate actors and investors.


That said, there is a presumption in the international system that shell companies present a real risk of money laundering, that there's additional due diligence and a risk determination that has to go along with any transaction or business relationship tied to shell companies. The risk is that banks or other elements of the legitimate commercial or financial system are being misused and that elements and vehicles of the economy are suddenly being put at the command of these organizations or these corporate vehicles that then allow them to move all sorts of illicit capital in and out of the U.S. market or other markets.


GAZETTE: How does money laundering threaten national security?


ZARATE: There are two fundamental national security implications. One is the ability of rogue actors - be they criminal organizations, nation-states in concert with proxies, terrorist organizations, all with the ability to access capital - to hide their proceeds, to gain profit, to meld it with a legitimate system. All are dangerous because that allows those groups to have profit and capital that allows them to do dangerous things. The reality is money laundering is an enabler for groups that present real threats to the United States and to its allies and to, frankly, international security. So that's a more tactical concern. The broader concern is about the challenge and threat to the integrity of the financial system. When we worry about … the U.S. or the global financial or commercial system, you worry about its safety, soundness, and integrity. And if much of the activity, or some significant portion of the activity in the economy, is derived from illicit gains, corrupt proceeds, illicit finance, that's an inherently unstable and dangerous system that presents real risk to the economic health of a country or the global economy and governance.


GAZETTE: Why weren't real estate closings, and those involved in them, required to abide by the anti-money-laundering requirements in the Patriot Act? And given The Times' series, as well as widespread anecdotal evidence, why is there only a temporary information-gathering program and not an enforcement action?


ZARATE: It's certainly not the first time authorities have worried about real estate being used as a money-laundering vehicle. That's in some ways a classic methodology and concern globally. The regulatory structure for the real estate market and actors is complicated. FinCEN has spoken to this issue before, even though real estate agents, title, and escrow companies are not considered financial institutions for purposes of the Bank Secrecy Act. I think the challenge is at what point do you best regulate the flow of funds in and out of the real estate market? That presents interesting questions about federalism and regulatory efficiency and a question as to whether or not regulation versus law enforcement attention is the right approach. So there's always been a question about what the right approach should be.


But with The New York Times expose, with the greater flow of funds into these key real estate markets, I think what FinCEN is trying to do is to not only understand better what's happening, but to build a record so as to begin to think about what the right regulatory structure looks like. And there is an interesting question as to who's ultimately responsible here for understanding beneficial ownership. Is it the title insurance industry? Is it the real estate broker? Is it some element of the financial-settlement process that has to happen? Part of this, too, is an exploration of where in the real estate process do you demand this type of enhanced diligence and clarity? That's in part what FinCEN's grappling with as well: Who's going to have access to that information and who can demand it.


GAZETTE: What do you expect the review will find, and is this a prelude to new enforcement?


ZARATE: FinCEN will undoubtedly discover problematic transactions and gaps in the real estate markets targeted. This all may result in some sort of demonstrative enforcement action. That is something that GTOs have tended to lead to in the past: law enforcement attention and focus, and then either law enforcement or regulatory action. So that's one potential result of this. The second is the fact-gathering allows FinCEN to think more aggressively about what anti-money-laundering regulation in the real estate space should look like and how best it should be implemented. And third is a marker for where else to potentially look for vulnerabilities, not just geographically, but it may demonstrate that there are other holes in the system that need to be looked at more carefully.


So the fact-gathering dimension of this is very helpful to make cases, to understand regulatory options, and then to also understand where vulnerabilities lie. I think it's inevitable that they're going to find things they hadn't seen to date, and the scope of the problem may be bigger than what we've seen reported.


GAZETTE: How might requiring disclosure of owners affect the way such properties are sold? Won't people just move to another vehicle?


ZARATE: It's a great question, and again it goes to what's the most effective way of getting this information and ensuring that it's vetted? Also, how do you ensure that you're not just creating one blockage in the system and allowing workarounds, either with new special-purpose vehicles or new processes that in essence layer further the ultimate beneficial ownership? That's a broader challenge of the anti-money-laundering system. How do you stay ahead of criminals and actors who are trying to hide sources of money and getting more sophisticated every time in using corporate formation, legalities, and layering to hide sources of wealth and sometimes ultimate beneficial ownership? It's just part of the organic process of dealing with anti-money laundering, trying to ensure accountability and transparency and traceability in the system. In this case, what that looks like for the real estate market is still in formation.


This interview was originally published in the Harvard Gazette on April 1, 2016. It has been edited by the publication for clarity and length.

Won't Cut Federal Spending? Then Cap The Cost Of Regulation

Last week a group of libertarian and conservative groups issued a coalition letter calling on Congress to cap regulatory costs. While some of us have long advocated experimenting with a regulatory budget (albeit not at the expense of not reducing government itself, nor of continuing to tolerate Congress' over-delegation to agencies), [...]